Broiled Mussels With Garlicky Herb Butter Recipe (2024)

Ratings

5

out of 5

198

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Carey Larsen

I served this as an appetizer for Easter dinner. Fantastic! I prepped the dish on Saturday, and it was so easy to pop the pan of mussels under the broiler as my lamb was resting. I used salted butter AND added the kosher salt, and the result was too salty. Should have either used unsalted butter as the recipe calls for, or skipped the salt. Or maybe the briny mussels would have been salty enough on their own. I substituted Ouzo for Pernod.

Eileen

I worked in a French restaurant years ago and we served something similar except with the addition of bread crumbs. I remember them being delicious!

Solleke

This is an excellent alternative to the escargots, even a little lighter, so more suitable as appetizer/entrée. As a native of Belgium, I love mussels. Now tell me where to order them fresh in the middle of nowhere, Nebraska...!

Aubrey

Made this with frozen in shell mussels from the Asian market. Amazing! Low effort, high protein dinner. Served with warm toasty baguette and butter.

PCB's

so, a little bit of heat on the butter mixture and it can be spooned on to the mussels a lot easier. My wife and love this recipe.

Tom Alvord

delicious!

Sandra

Great recipe. I made 4 lbs mussels as a dinner for 2. Will make this again as an hors d’oeuvre for a party. 1 stick butter more than enough for 4 lbs. I made compound butter ahead, rolled it into a log in plastic wrap and refrigerated it. Very easy to slice off and add to mussels. Since steaming liquid is discarded I used white wine & water. I reduced Pernod to 1 T in butter. Yummy!

WendyK

While this was an absolute fantastic appetizer-using exactly 2 lbs of mussels (devoured by 3 people), the herb/butter mixture was more than twice the amount necessary, even after using a generous amount! I had to freeze the remainder for future use.

Beth G.

We made this tonight, on Christmas Eve. My husband despises licorice and my son and I love it, so we compromised: I used Pastis in the cooking liquid but did not mix with the butter. I first thought that 2 cloves of garlic would not be enough, but I was wrong: it was perfect. This recipe was absolutely delicious and, while time consuming, was easy. I plan to make this for my next party, especially since it can be made ahead and broiled right before serving.

mudd

These look wonderful. A French restaurant (closed but not forgotten) in D.C. used to serve what they titled clams Provençal. This seems like what they served. Will try w/ clams.

Conner

Slightly annoying to put all the herb butter onto the individual mussels, but the results are wonderful. No matter what else we make with them there are never any mussels left over afterwards!

Eileen

I worked in a French restaurant years ago and we served something similar except with the addition of bread crumbs. I remember them being delicious!

Solleke

This is an excellent alternative to the escargots, even a little lighter, so more suitable as appetizer/entrée. As a native of Belgium, I love mussels. Now tell me where to order them fresh in the middle of nowhere, Nebraska...!

Megan

This is appetizers for a crowd or dinner for about 4-5 people. Works well, try other herbs instead of just parsley.

Carey Larsen

I served this as an appetizer for Easter dinner. Fantastic! I prepped the dish on Saturday, and it was so easy to pop the pan of mussels under the broiler as my lamb was resting. I used salted butter AND added the kosher salt, and the result was too salty. Should have either used unsalted butter as the recipe calls for, or skipped the salt. Or maybe the briny mussels would have been salty enough on their own. I substituted Ouzo for Pernod.

kidrid

Never use salted butter! For anything!

mudd

Don’t pay any attention to “don’t use salted butter for anything”! Many European butters are salted and cultured and they are wonderful in European “receipts”. Just don’t use it when unsalted is called for in American style recipes. If salted butter is all you have, eliminate all or most of the salt

Max Alexander

In America salted butter can be lesser quality. The salt prolongs the shelf life and can also hide off flavors. Salted butter in Europe is generally higher quality. I'm an American living in Rome.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Broiled Mussels With Garlicky Herb Butter Recipe (2024)

FAQs

What is the best method of cooking mussels? ›

Steaming is the most common method of cooking mussels.

Should you cook mussels that are already open? ›

Myth: Mussels have gone bad if they are open before cooking. Fact: Mussels that are open before cooking are most likely still alive. Give them a tap either with your finger or on the side of a bowl and wait for the shell to close up. If the shell does not close after tapping, then discard.

How do you know when mussels are cooked? ›

It's easy to tell when the mussels are cooked: when the mussels are finished cooking, their shells open up. So, keep an eye on the mussels, remove them from heat when their shells open up, and use the following as a guide for cooking times: 1-lb to 2-lbs: Steam 4-5 minutes. 2-lbs to 5-lbs: Steam 5-6 minutes.

How long should mussels be cooked? ›

Add the mussels to the pot and cover with the lid. Keep temperature to high. Cooking will take 5 to 7 minutes depending on the strength of heat, how much liquid you use, and the amount of mussels.

Do you have to put mussels in water before cooking? ›

Before cooking, soak your mussels in fresh water for about 20 minutes. As the mussels breathe, they filter water and expel sand. After about 20 minutes, the mussels will have less salt and sand stored inside their shells.

What has to be removed from mussels before cooking? ›

Pick up each mussel and check that it's firmly closed. Discard any mussels that are open – that's very important. Scrub each mussel clean with a stiff brush to get rid of any barnacles, pulling off the hairy 'beard' that sticks out from the shell, if it has one.

Should mussels be at room temperature before cooking? ›

The mussels can be scrubbed an hour before you serve them. Keep them in your fridge until right before you are going to cook them. Before cooking, check them again to make sure none have opened and won't close after a few taps; discard any that won't close.

Are mussels good for you? ›

Mussels are an excellent source of vitamins, including A, B2 and B12. These vitamins are essential for skin, building red blood cells, brain function, energy levels and maintaining a healthy immune system, which is especially important over the winter months.

How do you know if mussels have gone bad? ›

Buy mussels that look and smell fresh, with closed shells.

Press together the shells of any that are open. If the shell doesn't close, the mussel is dead and should be discarded (also toss any with broken shells).

How can you tell if mussels are undercooked? ›

One good way to know mussels are fully cooked is that their shells pop open when boiled or steamed, and the mussel inside is firm to the touch. Refrigerate shellfish as soon as possible after harvesting or purchasing from the supermarket.

What is the white stuff on mussels? ›

Barnacles and white worm grow on the outside of mussels' shells. To remove, scrape off with a blunt knife then rinse quickly under cold water. Rinse your mussels in cold running water.

What's good to eat with mussels? ›

Many cultures, chefs, and home cooks simply serve steamed mussels with crusty bread to sop up the juice or sauce, but you can also transform the briny bivalve into more involved dishes, from soup or salad to hearty pasta and more main courses.

How do you not overcook mussels? ›

The key is to cook them until they just open, usually 8-10 minutes. Overcooked mussels get chewy, so be sure to get them out of the pot when they open. If a couple of the mussels don't open after almost all are cooked, don't wait—discard them.

Can you cook mussels too long? ›

After about five minutes you should notice the steam is coming out from under the lid. Remove the mussels and serve in a bowl. Be careful not to overcook mussels as they can lose their flavour and become chewy. Add some fresh crusty bread to soak up the tasty broth and enjoy – it's that simple!

What are the different methods of cooking mussels? ›

There's lots to love about mussels: They're inexpensive, quick-cooking, readily available, and incredibly versatile, not to mention delicious! Mussels can be prepared with many methods — steamed, smoked, boiled, barbecued, or roasted.

Do mussels need to be soaked in salt water? ›

Saltwater helps preserve mussels, but they're unlikely to die in fresh water when soaked for a short time. Most mussels are farm-raised and are often cleaned before you buy them. However, it doesn't hurt to soak them to remove any remaining debris.

Why do you soak mussels in flour water? ›

Soaking live mussels in flour water cleans out any remaining grit, plumps up their meat, accentuates the meat's color to make it more orange, and gives them a creamier texture. The mussels will eventually drown if left in flour water long enough, so only do this a few hours ahead of cooking them.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gregorio Kreiger

Last Updated:

Views: 6003

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gregorio Kreiger

Birthday: 1994-12-18

Address: 89212 Tracey Ramp, Sunside, MT 08453-0951

Phone: +9014805370218

Job: Customer Designer

Hobby: Mountain biking, Orienteering, Hiking, Sewing, Backpacking, Mushroom hunting, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Gregorio Kreiger, I am a tender, brainy, enthusiastic, combative, agreeable, gentle, gentle person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.